The pizza just SUCKS - Goodfellas Pizza Sucks

Goodfellas Pizzeria sucks. Except, reading their online reviews you’d have no clue. Goodfellas seemingly pays content publishers to remove the negative reviews of their restaurant. Otherwise how else does every negative review disappear? Including the ones that several of our founders recently submitted.

The goal of this website is to provide a venue for negative first-hand experiences of Goodfellas Pizza since traditional review methods are unavailable.

0.0 Rating

The review below says it all.

View this post on Instagram

Barstool Pizza Review – Goodfellas (Lexington,KY)
A post shared by Dave Portnoy (@stoolpresidente) on Oct 8, 2018 at 3:00pm PDT

The Real Story

These screenshots show the truth rating of the business before they requested Google, Yelp, and other review websites to remove the negative reviews because they were hurting for business.

Google

Yelp

Feels Unsafe

Goodfellas Pizza has been known for incidents of violence.

Ask yourself, do you feel safe eating at a place where a woman got pushed into a glass partition and knocked unconscious? We’re requesting police logs for all their locations. A full list of incidents is to come.

Locations

INDIANAPOLIS, IN

MASS AVE
545 Massachusetts Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46204
317-602-3401

BROAD RIPPLE
914 Broad Ripple Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46220
317-744-0491

MAINSTRASSE VILLAGE
603 Main Street
Covington, KY 41011
859-916-5209

CINCINNATI, OH

OVER THE RHINE
1211 Main Street
Cincinnati, OH 45202
513-381-3625

PLEASANT RIDGE
6099 Montgomery Rd
Cincinnati, OH 45213
TBA

LEXINGTON, KY

MILL STREET
101 North Mill Street
Lexington, KY 40507
859-281-1101

DISTILLERY DISTRICT
1228 Manchester Street
Lexington, KY 40504
859-523-5280

tasteless cardboard

October 30, 2018

What happened? We stopped in for a few slices before drinks in the Distillery District. The choices of slices were limited so I selected the Margarita since it looked a little less “leftover”. Two slices of cold, tasteless cardboard. I keep asking myself why I think I will ever have superlative pizza in Lexington.

Absolute garbage

This place has no business calling themselves good fellas.. The pizza is terrible and the staff are complete jerks. Unbelievably bad customer service…

Chemical-tasting grease is what this pizza is!

So I’ve been hearing from a few girls at work that Goodfellas had great pizza. I decided I’d try it out with my boyfriend the other night- and it was VERY disappointing. It’s located in a bar which should have told me to stay away but I thought maybe it was a hidden treasure that only the party people knew about. First of all, I didn’t even see any pizza so I had to ask the bartender. It was at the other end of the place, and when we walked over to it, we saw a dimly-lit glass counter with old-looking pizza inside. I figured I’d try it anyway since people said it was good. Well, it was barely warm and there was a layer of shiny grease on top. It had this strange chemical taste to it, too! I thought maybe it was the cheese or sauce, but when I took a bite of just the crust, I could still taste it. The pieces are big like Sbarro’s in the mall but I couldn’t even eat half of mine, it was so bad. My boyfriend didn’t like it much but ate it all anyway and he ended up throwing up the next day! Maybe if you’re drunk, it tastes good, that’s all I can figure! DON’T EAT SOBER!https://www.tripadvisor.com.au/ShowUserReviews-g39588-d813050-r623842524-Goodfellas_Pizzeria-Lexington_Kentucky.html#

Cardboard pizza

Stopped in for a quick slice while in the area on business. When I got out to my rental car and took a bite, it was lukewarm and had the consistency of cardboard. Pretty disappointing after hearing the good reviews.

BLACKS SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THIS PLACE.....

The guy with the red beard is a racist. I ordered my pizza and then stood outside the door and waited. These two white girls came in that I actually held the door open for and ordered the same thing that I had already ordered. They did not have anymore pizza already prepared for them so he walks over to the other guy and whispered something in his ear and then proceeded to give them my food. I asked him why you gave them my food and he proceeded with racist disrespectful remarks. I’m in Lexington on a business trip for the first time and this experience has changed my perception of Lexington. I mean I know that in the downtown area is where they whipped slaves but I’m not a slave and will not be treated as such. I’m a website designer and I took pictures of the guy and plan to post them all over the internet once I return home. I plan to let as many people who will listen know about my experience. Flyers have been made and passed out throughout the city as well. This guy needs to be fired. BLACKS SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THIS PLACE…..